cjk123
Oct 9 2007, 11:22 AM
Alright well for some reason when I push the clutch in and try to shift into gear it grinds right away. If i push the clutch in and hold it for a second then go to shift it shifts just fine. Please help me out cuz this is my daily driver and I really cant afford to grind gears and ruin my tranny.
Do any of you know why it grinds unless I hold it down?
Could it be the slave cylinder itself going bad?
Could the master cylinder?
black92_tsi_awd
Oct 9 2007, 12:02 PM
Pull the boot back on the slave, if there's fluid replace it. Same deal on the master, there will be fluid on the firewall. I'd recommend replacing both if one is bad.
cjk123
Oct 9 2007, 12:32 PM
Is it if there is any fluid at all period? The slave is bone dry, but when I checked out the master was a slight bit of fluid, like it wasnt dripped down onto the fire wall or anything but there was a little fluid that i got on my fingers if i pulled the boot back and felt where the boot was.
black92_tsi_awd
Oct 9 2007, 01:49 PM
it's probably fine then.
You could try bleeding the system in case there's some air in it.
Is it grinding in all gears?
When I had I similiar problem, I replaced a leaking slave and master and then my clutch throw out bearing ended up failing.
cjk123
Oct 9 2007, 02:10 PM
I actually took it out and drove it. It seems to only be first and second that are doing it. I dont know why it just started today all the sudden though, before i could shift fine into second now i have to wait on it. I also didnt get on it hard so I do not know if the other gears would do it if i got on it and shifted hard
cjk123
Oct 9 2007, 02:15 PM
Is there anyone who knows a lot more about these cars than me that is willing to let me meet them somewhere and help me trouble shoot. I wish travis and christian still had their shop so I could go there.
cjk123
Oct 9 2007, 02:32 PM
Sorry man, im desperate
cjk123
Oct 9 2007, 10:31 PM
Well I guess I'm going to replace the slave cylinder, master cylinder, get an extended rod for the slave cylinder and change my tranny fluid as i know it is syncromesh but not sure how old since I just bought the car. Then also get my solid cable end bushings in.
I have not done the master cylinder on one of these cars before. As far as I can tell from looking at it and please tell me if I am wrong because I dont want to go to rip it out and be wrong and then have to ask.
1. Drain the brake fluid & remove the line that goes into the slave cylinder
2. Screw the slave rod all the way, not sure if this is a good idea or not, just seems much easier than trying to remove that cotter pin and deal with all of that.
3. Unbolt it from the engine side and pull it right out? (are there any bolts on the inside I need to remove?)
4. Put the new one it, screw the rod back in, hook the line back up to the slave and fill it.
5. Bleed it, how do I bleed the master cylinder? Where do I hook up the hose to bleed it or do I?
natedogg
Oct 10 2007, 08:53 AM
You bleed the master cylinder the same way you bleed the slave. You are essentially bleeding the entire clutch hydraulic system.
cjk123
Oct 10 2007, 11:23 AM
Alright, I kind of thought that after I posted but I figured I could still be wrong with that. Also Do I just unbolt it from the engine side and pull it out after the rod is disconnected from the inside?
black92_tsi_awd
Oct 10 2007, 12:01 PM
Yep, that's what I did.
Make sure you don't pump the master dry when bleeding, otherwise you have to start over.
I would just set the clevis that attaches to the clutch pedal close on the new master. You'll have to adjust it for the new slave/master anyway to get the clutch engaement pedal height right anyway.
cjk123
Oct 10 2007, 07:04 PM
Alright sounds good, I already got the slave and master, sadly I did not have time to get them done today and wont the next two days so It looks like sat morning will be when I put them in. Hopefully the master is as easy and slave was when I did that in my old car. I'm also going to install and extended slave rod, I have heard many statements about how they do nothing at all, but what the hell why not do it while I'm at it. Hopefully after the master, slave, extended rod, new syncromesh and solid end bushings the car will go back to shifting at least as good as it did before whatever happened the other day. I'll let you guys know how all of this goes.
cjk123
Oct 18 2007, 10:31 PM
Alright everything has been done to my tranny and still really no help at all. Through trouble shooting I'm kind of thinking its a bent clutch fork.
So I can do most work myself on this car but the tranny is something I have no experience with.
Out of the three dsms I've owned I have never had a tranny problem, I know luck me.
But basically I'm wondering about how much this would cost to fix if I took it somewhere and if anyone had any suggestions on where to take it.
Also how hard of a process would it been to drop the tranny and fix myself if I don't have the money to take it some place.
How bad will it mess up the car if at all if I just hold the clutch in for a slight second before shifting to prevent any grinding or anything like that until I can possibly get a tre tranny after winter?
Thanks for all you help to this points and hopefully future help.
black92_tsi_awd
Oct 19 2007, 06:49 AM
Dropping the trans is not that hard. I've done it quite a few times and I'm probably doing it again this weekend. You need a large floor jack to set it on. I use a transmission jack that has a large platform on it. It's nice because I usally pull them by myself.
I've got it down to about 2.0 hours to remove it, so at a $65 shop rate you'd probably pay someone $260 tp remove and them replace it. So I would definitely try to pull it yourself to save some labor costs.
If it doesn't turn out to not be the fork or throwout bearing, you looking at taking it somewhere to get fixed.
cjk123
Oct 19 2007, 01:35 PM
Okay so today I drained the whole system again, put in the extended clutch slave rod and then refilled and rebled the system. It seems to be a little better now.
I dont think I could have bled the line any more either time. Both times I used 64oz of fluid.
The pedal is stiffer than it used to be before I did all this but that wasn't the problem I was trying to fix. I will let you all know what happens when I take her out and drive her probably Sunday Night.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.